◀ BACK TO REVIEWS
REVIEW

Brass Birmingham Board Game Review: A Deep Dive into Industrial Strategy

Discover the intricacies of Brass Birmingham, a strategic economic game that captivates players with its depth and competition.

Morten Monrad Pedersen·2018·r/boardgames · community analysed
8.4
/ 10
PLAYERS2-4
PLAY TIME60-120 min
AGE14+
COMPLEXITY3.9 / 5
★ THE VERDICT

Brass Birmingham is a worthy evolution of its predecessor that combines strategic depth with intense competition, perfect for dedicated gamers.

✓ WHAT WORKS

  • Engaging strategic depth
  • Rich resource management
  • Interactive gameplay dynamics

✗ WHERE IT STUMBLES

  • Steep learning curve
  • Can overwhelm new players
  • Potential for analysis paralysis

THE FULL READ

Brass Birmingham is the modern iteration of the classic economic strategy game Brass, designed by Morten Monrad Pedersen. Released in 2018, it offers an updated experience while preserving the core mechanics that made the original a favorite among board game enthusiasts. Designed for 2-4 players aged 14 and up, the game introduces players to the industrial revolution's economic challenges, requiring keen strategic thinking and foresight.

In Brass Birmingham, players engage in a competitive struggle to build their industrial empire in the cities of Birmingham and its surrounding regions. The game is played over two eras: the canal era and the railroad era, with players needing to efficiently manage their resources such as coal, iron, and, most crucially, beer. This pivotal resource can make or break your strategies as players build breweries to supply their factories and satisfy customers. The gameplay involves constructing buildings and developing trade networks, each decision affecting the overall landscape of the competition.

What makes Brass Birmingham particularly engaging is its intricate balance of strategy and resource management. Players must navigate their development while adapting to opponents' moves, creating a dynamic and interactive game state. During play, many players have reported moments of intense thinking, often leading to analysis paralysis as they weigh their options carefully. This depth is part of what the community loves about the game, as many Reddit users have noted in their discussions. Some appreciate the newfound emphasis on beer in this version, highlighting its strategic importance in the later stages of the game. Others have shared their excitement for the thematic immersion and the historical context provided by the game's setting.

However, Brass Birmingham is not without its challenges. New players might find themselves overwhelmed by the complex rules and the depth of strategy involved. Critics on Reddit have highlighted the steep learning curve and how easily one can be caught off guard by the importance of resources like beer and coal. Mistakes early in the game can lead to missed opportunities and a frustrating experience for those not familiar with the mechanics. Additionally, some players have found the endgame particularly unforgiving, especially for those shifting from Brass Lancashire, where players may struggle with the game’s increased complexity.

For beginners, it’s essential to focus on understanding resource management and the importance of connecting your cities efficiently. A good tip is to prioritize acquiring beer production early on; this subtlety can have significant implications for your strategy down the road. Observing how veteran players manage their moves can also provide insight into effective tactics that lead to victorious outcomes.

In conclusion, Brass Birmingham stands out not only as an evolution of the beloved original but also as a standalone experience for fans of economic strategy games. While it has a steep learning curve, the rewarding nature of its gameplay and the rich strategy it offers make it an enticing option for those willing to invest the time. For serious gamers seeking a deep and competitive board game, Brass Birmingham delivers in ways few others can.

WHAT REDDIT IS SAYING

r/boardgames2m ago
Brass Birmingham leaving Steam at the end of the month.

Looks like Brass Birmingham is leaving Steam pretty suddenly as they said in a recent post that they'll be removing the game at the end of the month and have discounted it by 50%. Game looks to have some mixed reviews so I'm not sure if it's worth the $10 if that is basically being abandoned in about 5 days.

12644READ FULL THREAD →
★ TOP COMMENTS
  • u/Gifts2m ago

    Gifts from my gf (very excited about Brass Birmingham)

  • u/Brass2m ago

    Hey all. I was hoping to hear from people familiar with both games. Some quick back ground. I played and own the original Brass and was very familiar with it. One of my friends did get Brass Birmingham and I played it once but I remember being unimpressed with it. Like in a "if we already have Brass

  • u/Brass2m ago

    Just bought Brass Birmingham and played two games with my friends and was questioning if i got the rule about the links VPs wrong. When counting the VPs for the single links we always counted all the link symbols from all flipped industry tiles in the adjacent locations. Also the ones that are not

  • u/Found2m ago

    I have not seen the game in the flesh to be able to tell. Ia it best to not risk it with this one? Thanks all!

  • u/Bespoke2m ago

    So Brass is the first board game ever with our (pretty sophisticated) play group where **everyone** had to undo a turn at least once (and some people, multiple times) when they realized that the move they were planning is not possible - usually, but not always, due to the lack of access to coal. Tha

  • u/Is2m ago

    I googled, and it seems there wasn't; the app was unreliable and it was taken off BGA. But those posts were old, and I'm looking for an update.

◀ BACK TO REVIEWS