◀ BACK TO REVIEWS
REVIEW

BATTLESHIP: THE 90-YEAR-OLD GUESSING GAME WITH MORE STRATEGY THAN YOU THINK

A glorified coin-flip on the surface, a genuine probability puzzle once you understand parity. Still the cleanest 2-player deduction game on a shelf.

Clifford Von Wickler (original 1931 pencil-and-paper)·1931·r/boardgames · 287 comments
6.9
/ 10
PLAYERS2
PLAY TIME15–30 min
AGE7+
COMPLEXITY1.2 / 5
★ THE VERDICT

More strategy than its reputation suggests, but a one-trick experience. Good for a single 20-minute session, exhausted after five.

✓ WHAT WORKS

  • Real probability strategy emerges at intermediate skill
  • Parity hunting (only target same-color squares) doubles your hit rate
  • Cheap, fast, no setup beyond hiding ships
  • Universal recognition — anyone can play

✗ WHERE IT STUMBLES

  • Pure luck dominates the first 5–10 shots
  • Replayability is thin — same game every time
  • No catch-up mechanism if opponent gets early hits

THE FULL READ

Battleship is the game everyone played as a kid and few have played as an adult, which is a shame because there's a genuine probability puzzle hiding underneath the kids'-game packaging. Modern hobby gamers tend to dismiss it without realising the optimal strategy is non-trivial.

The single biggest discovery for intermediate players is *parity*. Battleship ships are all 2+ squares long, which means at least one of every two squares on the board must be empty (otherwise no ship could fit). If you only target squares matching one parity (think of a checkerboard pattern and only shoot the dark squares), you're guaranteed to hit every ship in half the shots — even a 2-square destroyer can't hide between two same-color squares. Going from random shooting to parity hunting cuts your average game length from ~60 shots to ~35.

The hunt-and-target loop matters. Once you score a hit, every adjacent square is a possible continuation. Shoot the four cardinal neighbours; once you score a second hit, the ship's orientation is locked, and you can finish it efficiently. Most players waste shots probing diagonal squares after a hit, which is impossible — ships don't bend.

Ship placement is the other half of the game and is consistently underrated. Most casual players cluster ships in corners (thinking opponents won't shoot there) — which is exactly where opponents *will* shoot once they realise parity sweeps cover the board evenly. The veteran placement is to scatter ships across the board with at least one square between any two ships, and to put the longest ships *near* the edges but not on them.

Battleship has had several modern reimaginings (Captain Sonar is a real-time team variant that's genuinely excellent; Operation Squad does ship-to-ship combat on a real grid). But the original remains a permanent fixture for what it is — a 20-minute, two-player, no-explanation-needed pickup game. Pull it out, parity-sweep, win in 35 shots, and put it away for another year.

WHAT REDDIT IS SAYING

r/boardgames6mo ago
What is the best version of battleship?

Me and my wife have been playing a lot of battleship lately as an easy little two player game. Works great because no one has to even think about reading the rules. But I was wondering amongst the many re-releases and other games in the same style, what are people’s favorite battleship type game?

018READ FULL THREAD →
★ TOP COMMENTS
  • u/jpwhite6mo ago

    Orapa Mine and/or Orapa space. Similar idea of "locate unknown objects" via coordinates but with a much more interesting decision and deduction space.

  • u/leseulsteve6mo ago

    Captain sonar is a pretty fun game, it's good for a group or just 2 people. You can play "turn base" or simultaly which get's wild :)

  • u/Stuntman066mo ago

    Battleship Galaxies.

  • u/raid_kills_bugs_dead6mo ago

    Two thoughts: * In the rules to the original game is the "Salvo" variant. This variant makes the game better. * Knizia made a game called *Battleship Express*.

  • u/ArcanistLupus6mo ago

    Electronic Star Wars battleship.  Besides the obvious (empire vs rebellion, plays movie quotes/makes turbolaser and explosion noises) it is also notable for playing on a Hex grid rather than a square grid

  • u/PurpleSlightlyRed6mo ago

    Pen and paper ver is the best

◀ BACK TO REVIEWS